top of page
USCCA graphic gold.png

News from the USCCA and the church in China

Fully Chinese, Fully Catholic: What the 1926 Consecrations Teach Us about Communion Today

17 hours ago
6 min read

On Nov 5, 2026, a conference, “The Universal Face of the Church in China,” took place in Rome to mark the centenary of the consecration of the first native Chinese bishops in the modern era. The following is a report and commentary on the event by Stephen Jiang.

"The First Six Bishops," Whitworth University (2017). Album 15: SAM and Chinese Students in Europe, 1929-1931. Paper 1. https://digitalcommons.whitworth.edu/album15/1
"The First Six Bishops," Whitworth University (2017). Album 15: SAM and Chinese Students in Europe, 1929-1931. Paper 1. https://digitalcommons.whitworth.edu/album15/1

One hundred years ago, six Chinese priests boarded a ship in Shanghai and sailed for a month to Rome. On October 28, 1926, beneath the dome of St. Peter’s Basilica, they received episcopal consecration from the hands of Pope Pius XI, becoming the first native Chinese bishops of the modern era. That historic voyage was meant to open a new chapter between the local Church in China and the Apostolic See.


A century later, bishops, scholars, and pastors gathered at Rome’s Pontifical Urban University for a conference titled "The Universal Face of the Church in China" to ask what that 1926 journey means today. Coinciding with the 80th anniversary of China’s diocesan hierarchy and building on the Urbaniana’s 2024 commemoration of the First Council of Shanghai, the gathering could easily have been reduced to polite historical nostalgia.


Instead, framed by a message from Pope Leo XIV and anchored by candid addresses from the Pro-Prefect of the Dicastery for Evangelization Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle, Cardinal Stephen Chow Sau-yan (周守仁) of Hong Kong, and Bishop Joseph Li Shan (李山) of Beijing, the conference offered a compelling vision for the present. Its central lesson was unmistakable: if the Catholic Church in China and the Vatican are to navigate their real and enduring differences, they must move beyond guarded monologues to practice the art of authentic dialogue. 


To understand why dialogue matters so deeply today, we must first appreciate what the 1926 consecrations achieved for episcopal communion with the Successor of Peter. In 1685, the Dominican Gregorio Luo Wenzao (羅文藻) was finally ordained the first Chinese bishop following sixteen years of political obstruction under the Portuguese Padroado. For more than two hundred years afterward, there was not a single native Chinese bishop. By the early twentieth century, Pope Benedict XV’s 1919 Apostolic Letter Maximum Illud and the 1924 Council of Shanghai, guided by Apostolic Delegate Archbishop Celso Costantini alongside prophetic figures like Fr. Vincent Lebbe (雷鳴遠) and Ma Xiangbo (馬相伯), insisted that the proclamation of the Gospel in China needed to take root within the culture of this particular land.


Yet when Zhao Huaiyi (趙懷義, 1880-1927), Chen Guodi (陳國砥, 1875-1930), Hu Ruoshan (胡若山, 1881-1962), Zhu Kaimin (朱開敏,1868-1960), Cheng Hede (成和德, 1873-1928), and Sun Dezhen (孫德禎, 1869-1951) traveled halfway across the world to be ordained in Rome, their journey signaled far more than a pragmatic shift in Vatican policy as colonialism faded. As Pope Leo XIV emphasized in his message, no pastor in the Church gives himself the mission. He only receives and exercises it in communion with the Successor of Peter and the bishops scattered throughout the world. Cardinal Tagle put the point with striking clarity: those six Chinese pioneers proved that bishops are neither "civil servants of God," nor local agents of a "politico-spiritual power," nor "influencers of the sacred." They are shepherds of souls connected by the unbroken thread of apostolic succession to the original eyewitnesses of the Risen Christ. By kneeling before the tomb of St. Peter, the bishops of 1926 showed that unity with the Pope is not about politics, colonialism, or foreign influence over China, but a bond of grace that brings joy and dignity to a local Church while anchoring it within the universal Church, the Mystical Body of Christ.


The question, then, is how to honor both that universal communion and China’s local reality. Speaking from the perspective of the Church in Mainland China, Bishop Joseph Li traced the effort to root Christianity in Chinese soil from Matteo Ricci’s arrival in Beijing in 1601 to today’s focus on the "Sinicization of Catholicism." For Bishop Li, Sinicization is not an attempt to invent a separate Catholicism detached from tradition, nor is it an optional ornament. Read through the lens of Vatican II, it is the necessary process by which the universality of Catholicism becomes concrete and mature within any particular culture. In faith, the Church in China is one with local Churches around the world and eager to walk together in synodality.


From there, Cardinal Chow offered the bridge needed to make genuine conversation possible. Asking how the Church can form believers who are simultaneously patriotic Chinese citizens and faithful Catholics, Cardinal Chow began with a disarming question: how many of us actually know how to dialogue? All too often, he observed, what passes for dialogue is simply two parties talking at each other in parallel monologues. Looking candidly at both traditional "inculturation," which can sometimes feel like outsiders trying to exert changes upon Chinese culture, and state-led "Sinicization," which carries many political expectations, Cardinal Chow shifted his focus to a third path rooted in Pope Benedict XVI’s concept of "interculturality." Rather than trying to conquer or lecturing from afar, intercultural dialogue invites both sides into a collaborative "Third Space." Practiced through the synodal method of "Conversation in the Spirit," it demands that dialogue partners examine their own blind spots, listen with empathy, and remain open to being changed by one another.


Cardinal Tagle wove these theological and pastoral insights together in the final speech of the conference. Echoing Pope Leo XIV’s teaching that Church unity is communion in diversity rather than uniformity, Tagle highlighted a central Christian paradox: the Church in China reveals its universal Catholic face precisely when it is fully and authentically Chinese. At the same time, he warned that without universal openness and communion with Rome, emphasizing local particularity always risks hardening into self-referential isolation and conflict. True dialogue, Tagle suggested, requires mutual contrition and forgiveness to heal historical wounds and a shift from a one-way missionary mentality to a joyful "exchange of gifts," where the perseverance and faith of Chinese Catholics can truly contribute to the universal Church.


No words, however, spoke more powerfully than the physical presence of the two Mainland bishops sitting in the room. Alongside Bishop Joseph Li sat his younger episcopal colleague, Bishop Ignatius Ding Zuyao (丁祖耀) of Haimen. Together, the older and younger prelates represented two distinct generations of the Catholic hierarchy in China. The elder bishop embodies a generation that has seen the Church through the complex decades of post-war transition and internal rebuilding, while the younger bishop represents an emerging cohort of pastors shepherding communities in a rapidly modernizing China. Seeing two generations of Mainland bishops in Rome is a reality that Cardinal Tagle noted was virtually unthinkable just a few years ago.


Bishop Ignatius Ding Zuyao, Cardinal Tagle, and Bishop Joseph Li
Bishop Ignatius Ding Zuyao, Cardinal Tagle, and Bishop Joseph Li

However, celebrating their presence in Rome does not mean ignoring the steep challenges that still confront Sino-Vatican relations. As speakers throughout the day acknowledged, the history of the Chinese Church carries deep scars: decades of external pressure, painful fractures among brothers in the faith, compromises, and lingering suspicions on both sides. Even today, reconciling the political demands of state-led Sinicization with the freedom of universal ecclesial communion remains a delicate, daily test of patience. Yet the encounter at the Urbaniana demonstrated why isolation is never the answer. As Cardinal Chow pointed out, tensions and disagreements are not necessarily bad things. They often signal needs that are waiting to be met or understood. When we sit together, share our experiences, and build up personal trust, our emotional posture toward one another shifts. Once trust is established, divisions that once looked insurmountable begin to open up to the influence of the Holy Spirit.


That spiritual reality found its highest expression in the morning after the conference. Before departing Rome, the two Chinese bishops walked together into St. Peter’s Basilica to pray before the tomb of the Apostle Peter. A hundred years after six Chinese priests arrived from Shanghai to receive the fullness of apostolic ministry at that very place, two generations of today’s Chinese prelates returned to this rock upon which the Church was established.


As Cardinal Tagle reflected, that quiet moment of prayer at Peter’s tomb was the most consoling gesture of the entire centenary, rescuing all the conference’s scholarly papers and speeches from the danger of becoming mere self-congratulation. It reminded the world that the unity of the Church is not born from treaties, negotiations, or human cleverness, but from the living water of apostolic faith, Christian hope, and charity realized in grace.

Additional links about the Conference, “The Universal Face of the Church in China”:


Video Message of the Holy Father Leo XIV:



Video Message of the Holy Father Leo XIV: Matthew Santucci, “100 Years after Historic Consecrations, Forum Examines Chinese Catholic Identity, Unity with Rome,” OSV News:



----------------------

The USCCA is a 501(c)3 tax-exempt organization. Your donations are tax-deductible to the maximum extent allowed by law. The success of our work depends upon the generosity of people like you.

The US-China Catholic Association was founded in 1989 by concerned U.S. bishops, Maryknoll, the Jesuits, and representatives of other religious orders in order to promote mutual support and fraternal ties between the Church in China and the U.S. Church.

Mailing address

​

US-China Catholic Association

1501 N. Oakley Blvd, #214

Chicago, IL 60622

​​

Email contact​

​

Director@USCatholicChina.org

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

The USCCA is a 501(c)3 tax-exempt organization. Your donations are tax-deductible to the maximum extent allowed by law. The success of our work depends upon the generosity of people like you.​​

​

© 2026 US-China Catholic Association

bottom of page